|
Columnists
Sustainability
and Sustainable Development

Nicholas
R. Hild, PhD Professor ASU
Polytechnic
Nicholas
R. Hild, PhD., Professor, Environmental Technology Management, Arizona
State University College of Technology and Innovation, has extensive
experience in Environmental Management in the southwestern U.S. Dr. Hild
can be reached at 480-727-1309 and by email at DrNick@asu.edu.
This
isn't Lake Wobegon, Toto . . .
Feb/Mar
2007
There
are many things I enjoy about living in the desert: the peace and
tranquility that accompany my morning coffee while looking out over the
Superstition Mountains and, on Sunday, listening to Garrison Keillor on
Prairie Home Companion are a couple that come to mind. While it’s true
that you can hear his two hour radio show from American Public Media on
NPR on Saturday, I find that the peacefulness of the desert and the
magnificent mountains somehow make his show on Sunday mornings extra
special, especially when he does his dialog about Lake Wobegon.
For
those of you who’ve not had the pleasure of listening to the show, one
of the regular features on the Minnesota-based PHC variety show is
updating the news from Lake Wobegon, a place that Keillor colorfully
describes as "the little town that time forgot and the decades
can not improve…" and where "all
the women are strong, the men are good looking, and the children are all
above average." In other words, it’s just the sort of place
that most of us have fantasized about living.
Lake
Wobegon is a place that’s mostly untouched by the harsh realities of the
world, where upper middle class families with Father-Knows-Best lives
are seemingly insulated from the normal tragedies that real-world
communities endure—yet its always a place PHC devotees look forward to
hearing about, every week probably because we unconsciously think that if
everything is still OK in Lake Wobegon, then the realities of the coming
week won’t be so hard to face.
What
got me thinking about Lake Wobegon was an article in the newspaper
recently about the upcoming downtown Phoenix road race that organizers are
now advertising as being a "green" event— a race that will
couple racing activities to "green" products vendors in a
sort of "eco-earth-friendly-fair" environment.
Talk
on the street is that Phoenix city council members and downtown business
interests remember the loss of revenues that accompanied the race the last
time they tried them through downtown so this time, promoters are spinning
the hype that they will have "green" businesses committed to
displaying their products in downtown as a backdrop before and during the
race "events."
The
organizers obviously think this must be a metropolis full of folks
recently relocated here from Lake Wobegon—they evidently think that the
citizens of our fair community will somehow be convinced that the race
will be a sustainability event just because, instead of 110 octane
gasoline, the fuel of choice will be methanol—that will bring together
(in their words) the "tree huggers to join hands
with the tragically hip…" which will see 150,000
green-seeking (?) race fans flock to the "largest green festival in
the country…" to see eco-conscious exhibits featuring
solar cars (on display; not running the race), environment-friendly
vendors (whatever that means), and organic food vendors who will change
the eating habits of race fans from red meat and beer to tofu and yogurt
shakes, just because it’s the "tragically hip"
thing to do (their words; not mine).
Its
clear that they need a PR person to teach these guys the art of being Politically
Correct before they insult everyone they are trying to bring into the
low octane mix!
As
both a "car person" and sustainability advocate, I am the
last to criticize trying to "brand" sustainability to
make it more mainstream but, somehow, the effort to bring in the "treehuggers"
(their word; not mine) to create a sustainable "impression"
about race cars that measure mileage in gallons per mile rather than mpg’s
(even if it IS methanol), reeks of a disingenuous attempt to
camouflage the real reason for gathering such disparate groups together—to
sell tickets and make money!
Race
organizers claim they are buying carbon credits for the emissions saved by
running methanol instead of gasoline (can they even do that???) and
putting the profits (profits—what profits?)
toward "earth-friendly technologies" (whatever those might be).
My take is, they are using all the right-sounding words to convince
the Phoenix business community and all those snowbirds who’ve fled the
Chatterbox Cafe in Lake Wobegon for winter sun in the valley, that
somehow, this will benefit our children’s, children’s, children.
2008/1234
|